BMW M4 for Sale in New York

Used 2015 BMW M4

Base

$23,170

88,960 mi

Est. $343/mo*

65 days on market

BlackSilverstone

Turn Auto Mall - New Hyde Park

Freeport, NY

Used 2015 BMW M4

Base

$28,565

85,485 mi

Est. $420/mo*

87 days on market

OrangeBlack

A1 Motors

West Hempstead, NY

Used 2017 BMW M4

Base

$32,888

82,761 mi

Est. $482/mo*

27 days on market

Alpine WhiteBlack

Lemans Cars

Commack, NY

Used 2020 BMW M4

Base

$46,700

35,427 mi

Est. $679/mo*

246 days on market

GreenBlack

Power Motors East

Massapequa Park, NY

Used 2019 BMW M4

CS

$47,900

37,891 mi

Est. $696/mo*

33 days on market

GrayBlack

Jerusalem Auto Inc.

Merrick, NY

Used 2018 BMW M4

Base

$53,654

34,828 mi

Est. $778/mo*

24 days on market

GrayGray

Select Motor Cars

Deer Park, NY

Used 2019 BMW M4

CS

$54,725

60,969 mi

Est. $793/mo*

209 days on market

GrayBlack

Beverly Hills Auto Group

Elmont, NY

Used 2022 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$57,170

39,621 mi

Est. $828/mo*

107 days on market

WhiteFiona Red/Black

Import Masters

Great Neck, NY

Used 2022 BMW M4

Base

$58,170

21,742 mi

Est. $842/mo*

193 days on market

Sao Paulo YellowBlue

Nissan 112

Patchogue, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

Base

$61,163

24,794 mi

Est. $885/mo*

113 days on market

Alpine WhiteBlack

Castle Car NY

Bellerose, NY

Used 2021 BMW M4

Base

$61,825

45,915 mi

Est. $894/mo*

141 days on market

BlackBlack

Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM FIAT Manhattan

New York, NY

Used 2024 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$70,890

23,026 mi

Est. $1,024/mo*

129 days on market

Alpine WhiteBlack

International Auto Sales

Long Island City, NY

Used 2023 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$71,675

Est. $1,035/mo*

11 days on market

BrownBlack

DeNooyer Chevrolet

Albany, NY

Used 2024 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$75,915

17,950 mi

Est. $1,095/mo*

64 days on market

Sao Paulo YellowBlack

Sunrise Chevrolet

Queens, NY

Used 2024 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$77,165

10,891 mi

Est. $1,113/mo*

53 days on market

GrayBlack

Sunrise Chevrolet

Queens, NY

Used 2024 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$78,875

11,327 mi

Est. $1,137/mo*

14 days on market

BlueTartufo

BMW Mt. Kisco

Mount Kisco, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$79,174

21,812 mi

Est. $1,142/mo*

11 days on market

BlueBlack

Auto Lux

Elmont, NY

Used 2024 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$79,174

12,750 mi

Est. $1,142/mo*

58 days on market

GrayFiona Red

Sunrise Autoland

Jamaica, NY

Used 2023 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$79,495

10,107 mi

Est. $1,146/mo*

20 days on market

BrownIvory White

Teddy Volkswagen of the Bronx

Bronx, NY

Used 2024 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$80,063

11,284 mi

Est. $1,154/mo*

175 days on market

BrownKyalami Orange

Long Island Sports Cars - Aston Martin Long Island - McLaren Long Island

Roslyn, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$83,175

12,181 mi

Est. $1,199/mo*

14 days on market

GrayBlack

Habberstad BMW

Huntington Station, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$85,175

29,265 mi

Est. $1,227/mo*

10 days on market

GrayBlack

Habberstad BMW

Huntington Station, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$85,646

6,618 mi

Est. $1,234/mo*

19 days on market

White

Competition BMW of Smithtown

Saint James, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$85,675

13,272 mi

Est. $1,234/mo*

11 days on market

Black

Habberstad BMW

Huntington Station, NY

New 2026 BMW M4

Base

$86,800

13 mi

Est. $1,250/mo*

110 days on market

Alpine WhiteBlack

BMW of Long Island City

Long Island City, NY

New 2026 BMW M4

Base

$88,510

15 mi

Est. $1,275/mo*

52 days on market

Sao Paulo YellowBlack

Wide World BMW

Spring Valley, NY

Used 2026 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$91,375

3,008 mi

Est. $1,316/mo*

22 days on market

Alpine WhiteBlack

BMW Mt. Kisco

Mount Kisco, NY

Used 2022 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$91,590

19,367 mi

Est. $1,319/mo*

143 days on market

BlackBlack

SR Auto Group

Bayside, NY

Used 2026 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$93,075

1,554 mi

Est. $1,340/mo*

50 days on market

GrayBlack

Ferrari of Long Island

Plainview, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition

$98,205

13 mi

Est. $1,413/mo*

27 days on market

Special Order ColorFiona Red/Black

Rallye BMW

Westbury, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$99,455

16 mi

Est. $1,431/mo*

10 days on market

GrayBlack

BMW of Bay Shore

Bay Shore, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$106,105

5 mi

Est. $1,526/mo*

1 day on market

Gray

Habberstad BMW

Huntington Station, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$106,729

0 mi

Est. $1,534/mo*

56 days on market

GrayTartufo

BMW Mt. Kisco

Mount Kisco, NY

Used 2026 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$112,174

8,473 mi

Est. $1,612/mo*

91 days on market

GreenWhite

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$112,347

5 mi

Est. $1,615/mo*

69 days on market

Gentian BlueYas Marina Blu

BMW of Manhattan

New York, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$112,600

0 mi

Est. $1,618/mo*

50 days on market

Audi Rochester

Rochester, NY

New 2027 BMW M4

Competition xDrive

$116,525

5 mi

Est. $1,674/mo*

1 day on market

WhiteGray

Habberstad BMW

Huntington Station, NY

Used 2025 BMW M4

CS

$149,800

11,026 mi

Est. $2,148/mo*

100 days on market

GreenAnthracite

Alpha Auto Long Island

Westbury, NY