Tesla Model Y for Sale in New York

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,980

88,809 mi

Est. $298/mo*

41 days on market

WhiteWhite

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$21,800

99,040 mi

Est. $324/mo*

1 day on market

GrayBlack

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,024

72,018 mi

Est. $327/mo*

168 days on market

WhiteBlack

Victory Cars Central

Levittown, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,390

68,923 mi

Est. $332/mo*

33 days on market

BlackBlack

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,690

71,287 mi

Est. $337/mo*

33 days on market

WhiteBlack

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,980

65,685 mi

Est. $341/mo*

33 days on market

BlueBlack

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$23,770

73,549 mi

Est. $352/mo*

248 days on market

BlackBlack

Pristine Mitsubishi

Commack, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$24,584

48,371 mi

Est. $364/mo*

13 days on market

Red MultiWhite / Black

Best Auto Outlet Inc.

Floral Park, NY

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$24,795

93,318 mi

Est. $367/mo*

76 days on market

GrayBlack

Auto Outlets Usa

Farmington, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,477

52,673 mi

Est. $376/mo*

65 days on market

WhiteWhite / Black

Best Auto Outlet Inc.

Floral Park, NY

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,675

51,630 mi

Est. $393/mo*

138 days on market

GrayBlack

Tower Auto Sales

Schenectady, NY

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,894

49,311 mi

Est. $411/mo*

300 days on market

BlueBlack

Brooklyn Auto Mall LLC

Brooklyn, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$27,995

45,262 mi

Est. $412/mo*

113 days on market

GrayGray

Bulldog Auto Sales

Schenectady, NY

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,800

45,740 mi

Est. $424/mo*

64 days on market

BlackBlack

Yes Auto

Elmhurst, NY

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,894

35,699 mi

Est. $425/mo*

198 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Freedom Chevrolet

Fort Montgomery, NY

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,995

34,884 mi

Est. $427/mo*

27 days on market

White

Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac

Bay Shore, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,190

36,693 mi

Est. $429/mo*

95 days on market

WhiteWhite/Black

SR Auto Group

Bayside, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,843

24,493 mi

Est. $439/mo*

100 days on market

WhiteBlack

Freedom Chevrolet

Fort Montgomery, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,170

46,931 mi

Est. $443/mo*

35 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Volkswagen of West Islip

West Islip, NY

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,170

22,614 mi

Est. $443/mo*

119 days on market

White

Victory Mitsubishi

Bronx, NY

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,690

39,107 mi

Est. $451/mo*

33 days on market

GrayWhite

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$31,070

37,377 mi

Est. $456/mo*

49 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Freedom Chevrolet

Fort Montgomery, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,170

37,669 mi

Est. $458/mo*

38 days on market

GrayBlack

Freedom Chevrolet

Fort Montgomery, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$31,395

27,926 mi

Est. $461/mo*

114 days on market

Red Multi-CoatWhite/Black

Auto Outlets Usa

Farmington, NY

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,823

17,995 mi

Est. $467/mo*

102 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Freedom Chevrolet

Fort Montgomery, NY

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,849

34,619 mi

Est. $467/mo*

12 days on market

BlackBlack

Romeo Chevrolet

Glens Falls, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$32,332

69,253 mi

Est. $474/mo*

48 days on market

WhiteBlack

Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM FIAT Manhattan

New York, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$32,595

41,802 mi

Est. $478/mo*

86 days on market

WhiteBlack

Auto Outlets Usa

Farmington, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,125

24,978 mi

Est. $485/mo*

138 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Queens Vans LLC

Woodside, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,595

36,859 mi

Est. $492/mo*

66 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Auto Outlets Usa

Farmington, NY

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,675

19,479 mi

Est. $493/mo*

65 days on market

DeNooyer Chevrolet

Albany, NY

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,800

19,035 mi

Est. $524/mo*

9 days on market

GrayBlack

Certified Luxury Motors

Great Neck, NY

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,995

27,094 mi

Est. $526/mo*

65 days on market

GrayBlack

Auto Outlets Usa

Farmington, NY

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$37,395

22,004 mi

Est. $546/mo*

111 days on market

Stealth GreyBlack

Auto Outlets Usa

Farmington, NY

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$37,679

21,635 mi

Est. $550/mo*

34 days on market

GrayBlack

Huntington Honda

Huntington, NY

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$37,864

46,769 mi

Est. $553/mo*

49 days on market

Stealth GreyWhite/Black

Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM FIAT Manhattan

New York, NY

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$40,773

27,122 mi

Est. $594/mo*

12 days on market

BlackBlack

Zing Auto Inc.

Mineola, NY

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$41,675

17,995 mi

Est. $607/mo*

18 days on market

RedBlack

Tasca Dodge Jeep RAM Chrysler

Elmsford, NY

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$43,498

11,100 mi

Est. $633/mo*

52 days on market

Gray

MINI of Freeport

Freeport, NY

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Premium

$49,879

2,845 mi

Est. $724/mo*

10 days on market

BlackBlack

Acura of Westchester

Larchmont, NY