Tesla Model Y for Sale in New York
Live Tesla Model Y inventory in New York, priced low to high.
52 listings · $18,980 – $47,070
Used 2020 Tesla Model Y
$18,980
Est. $284/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$19,595
Est. $293/mo*
Auto Empire, LLC
Used 2020 Tesla Model Y
$20,670
Est. $308/mo*
Turn Auto Mall - New Hyde Park
Used 2020 Tesla Model Y
$20,924
Est. $311/mo*
Victory Cars Central
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$21,980
Est. $327/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$22,295
Est. $331/mo*
Import Masters
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$22,390
Est. $332/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$22,490
Est. $334/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$22,690
Est. $337/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$23,170
Est. $343/mo*
Import Masters
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$23,290
Est. $345/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$23,950
Est. $355/mo*
Driven Automotive
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$24,135
Est. $357/mo*
Volkswagen of West Islip
Used 2020 Tesla Model Y
$24,170
Est. $358/mo*
Auto Outlets Usa
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$24,890
Est. $368/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2020 Tesla Model Y
$24,894
Est. $368/mo*
Freedom Chevrolet
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$24,900
Est. $368/mo*
Atlantic Chevrolet Cadillac
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$24,965
Est. $369/mo*
Import Masters
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$24,970
Est. $369/mo*
Pristine Mitsubishi
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$24,980
Est. $369/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$26,163
Est. $386/mo*
Acura of Bay Shore
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$26,688
Est. $394/mo*
Ideal Automotive Sales of Bensonhurst
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$26,989
Est. $398/mo*
Interstate Toyota
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$27,174
Est. $401/mo*
Basil Toyota
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$27,894
Est. $411/mo*
Brooklyn Auto Mall LLC
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$27,980
Est. $412/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2024 Tesla Model Y
$27,995
Est. $412/mo*
Freedom Chevrolet
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$28,250
Est. $416/mo*
Romeo Chevrolet
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$28,516
Est. $420/mo*
Empire Toyota of Huntington
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$28,670
Est. $422/mo*
Nassau Auto Mall
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$28,944
Est. $426/mo*
Freedom Chevrolet
Used 2020 Tesla Model Y
$29,715
Est. $437/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$29,801
Est. $438/mo*
Yes Autos
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$30,070
Est. $442/mo*
Freedom Chevrolet
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$30,136
Est. $443/mo*
Best Auto Outlet Inc.
Used 2021 Tesla Model Y
$31,074
Est. $456/mo*
Basil Toyota
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$31,500
Est. $462/mo*
EZ Auto 1
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$31,949
Est. $469/mo*
Mazda of New Rochelle
Used 2022 Tesla Model Y
$32,072
Est. $470/mo*
Romeo Chevrolet
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$33,474
Est. $490/mo*
Biener Ford
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$33,670
Est. $493/mo*
Freedom Chevrolet
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$34,070
Est. $499/mo*
Volkswagen of West Islip
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$34,414
Est. $504/mo*
Mercedes-Benz of Brooklyn
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$34,700
Est. $508/mo*
Otis Ford
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$35,170
Est. $515/mo*
Empire Ford of Huntington
Used 2025 Tesla Model Y
$35,375
Est. $517/mo*
Millennium Chevrolet
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$36,170
Est. $529/mo*
Auto Outlets Usa
Used 2023 Tesla Model Y
$36,715
Est. $537/mo*
Certified Luxury Motors
Used 2025 Tesla Model Y
$39,674
Est. $579/mo*
Zing Auto Inc.
Used 2026 Tesla Model Y
$39,894
Est. $582/mo*
Freedom Chevrolet
Used 2024 Tesla Model Y
$40,630
Est. $592/mo*
Tasca Dodge Jeep RAM Chrysler
Used 2026 Tesla Model Y
$47,070
Est. $684/mo*
Keeler Honda