Tesla Model Y for Sale in New Jersey

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$10,698

185,152 mi

Est. $166/mo*

72 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$11,698

224,765 mi

Est. $180/mo*

134 days on market

Red Multi-Coat

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$14,698

185,388 mi

Est. $223/mo*

241 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$16,698

151,065 mi

Est. $251/mo*

149 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$16,698

137,529 mi

Est. $251/mo*

156 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$16,698

157,753 mi

Est. $251/mo*

97 days on market

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$16,849

169,899 mi

Est. $253/mo*

60 days on market

BlueBlack

Premier Automotive Group

Belleville, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$17,497

125,837 mi

Est. $263/mo*

212 days on market

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$17,497

115,200 mi

Est. $263/mo*

234 days on market

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$17,997

144,991 mi

Est. $270/mo*

167 days on market

Whi

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$17,997

165,368 mi

Est. $270/mo*

99 days on market

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$18,497

168,560 mi

Est. $277/mo*

122 days on market

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,497

147,135 mi

Est. $291/mo*

122 days on market

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$20,497

133,499 mi

Est. $305/mo*

94 days on market

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$20,497

134,239 mi

Est. $305/mo*

136 days on market

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$20,698

126,346 mi

Est. $308/mo*

108 days on market

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$21,698

134,559 mi

Est. $323/mo*

122 days on market

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$21,698

140,201 mi

Est. $323/mo*

122 days on market

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$21,997

133,312 mi

Est. $327/mo*

66 days on market

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$21,997

121,067 mi

Est. $327/mo*

74 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$22,494

122,418 mi

Est. $334/mo*

106 days on market

BlueBlack

NJ Auto Sales

South Amboy, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,698

143,429 mi

Est. $337/mo*

134 days on market

Pearl

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,798

48,355 mi

Est. $338/mo*

15 days on market

Black

NASA Auto Sales

Passaic, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,997

143,429 mi

Est. $341/mo*

74 days on market

WhiteWhite/Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$22,997

135,946 mi

Est. $341/mo*

74 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$23,997

119,397 mi

Est. $355/mo*

8 days on market

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$23,997

153,714 mi

Est. $355/mo*

15 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$24,783

65,107 mi

Est. $366/mo*

86 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Auto Hub

North Brunswick, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$24,798

100,790 mi

Est. $367/mo*

66 days on market

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$24,997

80,026 mi

Est. $370/mo*

74 days on market

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,598

51,855 mi

Est. $378/mo*

111 days on market

WhiteBlack

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,763

101,099 mi

Est. $380/mo*

70 days on market

White

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$26,290

62,465 mi

Est. $388/mo*

100 days on market

Blue

J&S Mitsubishi

Ewing, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,298

81,879 mi

Est. $388/mo*

44 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,489

52,936 mi

Est. $391/mo*

7 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,498

41,675 mi

Est. $391/mo*

68 days on market

WhiteBlack

Autopia

Union, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,625

70,118 mi

Est. $393/mo*

45 days on market

BlueBlack

Lilliston Ford

Vineland, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,794

53,975 mi

Est. $395/mo*

17 days on market

Solid BlackWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,988

73,498 mi

Est. $398/mo*

39 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,998

65,704 mi

Est. $398/mo*

1 day on market

WhiteBlack

VIP Auto Outlet - Maple Shade Township

Maple Shade Township, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,999

61,561 mi

Est. $398/mo*

25 days on market

Kars 4 Sale LLC

Little Ferry, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,448

53,757 mi

Est. $404/mo*

56 days on market

Blue

Bridgewater KIA

Bridgewater, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,489

64,971 mi

Est. $405/mo*

2 days on market

GrayBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,953

57,529 mi

Est. $412/mo*

28 days on market

WhiteBlack

Land Rover Parsippany

Parsippany-Troy Hills Township, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,997

96,535 mi

Est. $412/mo*

28 days on market

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,489

51,776 mi

Est. $419/mo*

10 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,790

51,002 mi

Est. $424/mo*

1 day on market

Black

J&S Mitsubishi

Ewing, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,888

36,615 mi

Est. $425/mo*

56 days on market

Gray

Europlus Motorsport

Somerset, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,994

32,413 mi

Est. $427/mo*

6 days on market

BlueBlack

Prestige Toyota

Ramsey, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,294

31,699 mi

Est. $431/mo*

69 days on market

WhiteWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues of Sewell

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,798

39,436 mi

Est. $438/mo*

71 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,798

44,371 mi

Est. $438/mo*

50 days on market

GrayBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,989

49,319 mi

Est. $441/mo*

3 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,989

40,152 mi

Est. $441/mo*

17 days on market

GrayBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,995

34,467 mi

Est. $441/mo*

50 days on market

Olger Motors

Woodbridge, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,198

36,501 mi

Est. $444/mo*

56 days on market

BlackBlack

Hyundai of Trenton

Ewing, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,294

33,303 mi

Est. $445/mo*

32 days on market

Solid BlackWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,489

31,022 mi

Est. $448/mo*

37 days on market

GrayBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,489

56,168 mi

Est. $448/mo*

46 days on market

RedBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,494

51,552 mi

Est. $448/mo*

44 days on market

BlueBlack

Toms River Volkswagen

Toms River, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,593

49,308 mi

Est. $449/mo*

22 days on market

BlueBlack

Haldeman Subaru

Robbinsville, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,688

51,052 mi

Est. $451/mo*

10 days on market

Matt Blatt Mitsubishi

Glassboro, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,790

61,339 mi

Est. $452/mo*

61 days on market

Red MultiWhite / Black

J&S Mitsubishi

Ewing, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,794

31,360 mi

Est. $452/mo*

18 days on market

WhiteWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues of Sewell

Sewell, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,794

25,469 mi

Est. $452/mo*

70 days on market

WhiteBlack

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$30,798

24,000 mi

Est. $452/mo*

60 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,799

36,617 mi

Est. $452/mo*

66 days on market

WhiteBlack

BM Motorcars

Linden, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,889

51,616 mi

Est. $454/mo*

29 days on market

White

BM Motorcars

Linden, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,199

46,892 mi

Est. $458/mo*

21 days on market

BlackWhite / Black

Freehold Dodge & Subaru

Freehold, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,294

34,296 mi

Est. $459/mo*

142 days on market

SilverWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,294

31,346 mi

Est. $459/mo*

35 days on market

WhiteBlack

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,298

40,672 mi

Est. $459/mo*

44 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$31,489

47,839 mi

Est. $462/mo*

7 days on market

GrayBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,489

26,749 mi

Est. $462/mo*

17 days on market

Red MultiBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,494

74,536 mi

Est. $462/mo*

17 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Toms River Volkswagen

Toms River, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,794

35,962 mi

Est. $466/mo*

50 days on market

SilverBlack

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$31,884

28,183 mi

Est. $468/mo*

139 days on market

Solid BlackWhite/Black

Euro Lux Auto

Hillside, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$31,989

34,460 mi

Est. $469/mo*

50 days on market

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$32,158

32,032 mi

Est. $472/mo*

91 days on market

RedBlack

Crown Cadillac, Inc.

Watchung, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$32,298

24,162 mi

Est. $474/mo*

32 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,245

58,623 mi

Est. $487/mo*

11 days on market

GrayBlack

Maserati of Monmouth

Ocean, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,395

41,068 mi

Est. $489/mo*

49 days on market

GrayWhite/Black

Toms River Volkswagen

Toms River, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,598

28,735 mi

Est. $492/mo*

93 days on market

Lucas Chevrolet

Lumberton, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,598

43,683 mi

Est. $492/mo*

105 days on market

Lucas Chevrolet

Lumberton, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,739

36,169 mi

Est. $494/mo*

70 days on market

Gray

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,786

55,568 mi

Est. $495/mo*

12 days on market

GrayBlack

Paul Miller Inc. DBA Paul Miller Audi

Pinebrook, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,990

45,294 mi

Est. $498/mo*

81 days on market

Not Specified

Premier Auto Group

Turnersville, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,991

34,272 mi

Est. $498/mo*

25 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$34,298

13,097 mi

Est. $502/mo*

67 days on market

WhiteWhite/Black

KIA of Riverdale

Riverdale, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$34,838

35,382 mi

Est. $510/mo*

7 days on market

BlackBlack

Hyundai of Trenton

Ewing, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$34,977

38,838 mi

Est. $512/mo*

50 days on market

WhiteBlack

Euro Lux Auto

Hillside, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$34,989

49,472 mi

Est. $512/mo*

41 days on market

BlackBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$34,996

15,189 mi

Est. $512/mo*

5 days on market

WhiteBlack

Yes Motors

Orange, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,794

19,077 mi

Est. $523/mo*

50 days on market

BlackWhite

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,390

23,035 mi

Est. $532/mo*

34 days on market

Gray

Victory Subaru

Somerset, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$36,593

35,695 mi

Est. $535/mo*

50 days on market

BlackBlack

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,598

28,735 mi

Est. $535/mo*

93 days on market

Lucas Chevrolet

Lumberton, NJ

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,890

35,259 mi

Est. $539/mo*

25 days on market

BlackBlack

Axis Auto Group

Jersey City, NJ

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,988

17,990 mi

Est. $540/mo*

47 days on market

BlueBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$37,294

23,176 mi

Est. $545/mo*

60 days on market

Stealth GreyBlack

Automotive Avenues of Sewell

Sewell, NJ