Tesla Model Y for Sale in New Jersey

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$12,949

142,462 mi

Est. $198/mo*

18 days at this dealer

Red Multi-Coat

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$16,849

169,899 mi

Est. $253/mo*

113 days at this dealer

BlueBlack

Premier Automotive Group

Belleville, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$17,449

165,368 mi

Est. $262/mo*

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$17,949

100,790 mi

Est. $269/mo*

20 days at this dealer

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$17,949

168,560 mi

Est. $269/mo*

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$17,949

133,499 mi

Est. $269/mo*

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$18,949

153,714 mi

Est. $283/mo*

68 days at this dealer

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$18,949

143,429 mi

Est. $283/mo*

20 days at this dealer

WhiteWhite/Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,200

147,135 mi

Est. $287/mo*

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,406

142,166 mi

Est. $290/mo*

12 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Hudson Honda in West New York

West New York, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,449

133,312 mi

Est. $290/mo*

20 days at this dealer

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,589

160,986 mi

Est. $292/mo*

4 days at this dealer

Solid Black

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,590

90,239 mi

Est. $292/mo*

3 days at this dealer

BlueWhite

Luxurious Auto Sales Inc.

Plainfield, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$19,700

134,239 mi

Est. $294/mo*

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$19,984

116,900 mi

Est. $298/mo*

49 days at this dealer

WhiteWhite/Black

Ron Motor Inc.

Wantage, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$20,200

126,346 mi

Est. $301/mo*

Grey

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$20,449

135,946 mi

Est. $305/mo*

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$20,690

119,276 mi

Est. $308/mo*

10 days at this dealer

SilverBlack

Best Cars R Us LLC, Plainfield

Plainfield, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$21,200

140,201 mi

Est. $315/mo*

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$21,449

143,429 mi

Est. $319/mo*

Pearl

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,949

122,183 mi

Est. $340/mo*

39 days at this dealer

White

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$22,988

104,057 mi

Est. $341/mo*

4 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$23,309

99,168 mi

Est. $345/mo*

6 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Burns Honda

Marlton, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$23,449

119,397 mi

Est. $347/mo*

61 days at this dealer

Blue

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$23,898

93,167 mi

Est. $354/mo*

39 days at this dealer

GrayBlack

Hyundai of Trenton

Ewing, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$24,981

126,321 mi

Est. $369/mo*

17 days at this dealer

Solid BlackBlack

Smythe Volvo Cars

Summit, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,491

74,113 mi

Est. $377/mo*

4 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,598

65,704 mi

Est. $378/mo*

49 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

VIP Auto Outlet - Maple Shade Township

Maple Shade Township, NJ

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,788

76,870 mi

Est. $381/mo*

4 days at this dealer

Gray

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$25,799

64,099 mi

Est. $381/mo*

35 days at this dealer

GrayWhite

Square One Auto

Rahway, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$25,999

41,675 mi

Est. $384/mo*

WhiteBlack

Autopia Motorcars Inc.

Union, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$26,294

66,215 mi

Est. $388/mo*

45 days at this dealer

Blue

Toms River Volkswagen

Toms River, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,299

54,537 mi

Est. $388/mo*

17 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,299

81,879 mi

Est. $388/mo*

94 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,485

78,438 mi

Est. $391/mo*

BlackBlack

Car2Sell

Hillside, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$26,799

77,548 mi

Est. $395/mo*

10 days at this dealer

BlackWhite / Black

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$26,949

96,535 mi

Est. $397/mo*

82 days at this dealer

Solid Black

Auto Market Street

Paterson, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,789

59,842 mi

Est. $409/mo*

39 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Holman Cadillac

Mount Laurel, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,790

46,447 mi

Est. $409/mo*

10 days at this dealer

WhiteWhite

Haus of Lux

Wayne, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,894

52,881 mi

Est. $411/mo*

38 days at this dealer

WhiteWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,900

62,749 mi

Est. $411/mo*

6 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Lighthouse Motors Inc.

Pleasantville, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$28,294

31,699 mi

Est. $417/mo*

20 days at this dealer

WhiteWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,299

49,319 mi

Est. $417/mo*

52 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,299

51,776 mi

Est. $417/mo*

60 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,494

35,463 mi

Est. $419/mo*

24 days at this dealer

SilverWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,688

51,052 mi

Est. $422/mo*

60 days at this dealer

Matt Blatt Mitsubishi

Glassboro, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$28,794

33,303 mi

Est. $424/mo*

81 days at this dealer

Solid BlackWhite/Black

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$28,890

80,633 mi

Est. $425/mo*

15 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Axis Auto Group

Jersey City, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,790

66,902 mi

Est. $438/mo*

4 days at this dealer

White

J&S Mitsubishi

Ewing, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,790

61,339 mi

Est. $438/mo*

103 days at this dealer

Red MultiWhite / Black

J&S Mitsubishi

Ewing, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,794

31,346 mi

Est. $438/mo*

86 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,797

40,672 mi

Est. $438/mo*

20 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,798

39,436 mi

Est. $438/mo*

20 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,799

48,723 mi

Est. $438/mo*

6 days at this dealer

Solid BlackBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$29,799

43,124 mi

Est. $438/mo*

6 days at this dealer

Solid BlackWhite/Black

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,296

61,735 mi

Est. $445/mo*

3 days at this dealer

Gray

Chrysler Jeep Dodge RAM of Princeton

Elmwood Park, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,564

65,236 mi

Est. $449/mo*

4 days at this dealer

Solid Black

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,798

56,168 mi

Est. $452/mo*

97 days at this dealer

Ultra RedBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,298

24,162 mi

Est. $459/mo*

82 days at this dealer

Solid BlackBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$31,298

24,000 mi

Est. $459/mo*

103 days at this dealer

Solid BlackBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$31,299

34,460 mi

Est. $459/mo*

101 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Standard Range

$31,587

22,573 mi

Est. $463/mo*

52 days at this dealer

GrayBlack

Johnson Ford Burlington

Burlington, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$31,990

45,294 mi

Est. $469/mo*

20 days at this dealer

Not Specified

Premier Auto Group

Turnersville, NJ

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$32,036

65,604 mi

Est. $470/mo*

3 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Lester Glenn Hyundai Toms River

Toms River, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$32,460

53,398 mi

Est. $476/mo*

15 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Mercedes-Benz of Paramus

Paramus, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$32,490

29,162 mi

Est. $476/mo*

3 days at this dealer

Solid Black

Maserati & Alfa Romeo of Englewood Cliffs

Englewood Cliffs, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$32,491

28,512 mi

Est. $476/mo*

3 days at this dealer

SilverWhite/Black

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$32,998

43,683 mi

Est. $484/mo*

20 days at this dealer

Lucas Chevrolet

Lumberton, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,216

23,172 mi

Est. $487/mo*

10 days at this dealer

BlueBlack

Jersey City KIA

Jersey City, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,288

54,847 mi

Est. $488/mo*

4 days at this dealer

White

AutoShow (Neptune City)

Neptune City, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,478

35,163 mi

Est. $490/mo*

10 days at this dealer

WhiteWhite/Black

Quality Autos LLC

Hamburg, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,589

63,124 mi

Est. $492/mo*

18 days at this dealer

Solid BlackBlack

NY Auto Depot

Highland Park, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,598

51,020 mi

Est. $492/mo*

20 days at this dealer

SilverBlack

Lucas Chevrolet

Lumberton, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,991

19,635 mi

Est. $498/mo*

3 days at this dealer

Red Multi-Coat

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$34,738

26,553 mi

Est. $508/mo*

14 days at this dealer

Princeton BMW

Hamilton, NJ

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$34,996

15,189 mi

Est. $512/mo*

59 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Yes Motors

Orange, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,248

35,417 mi

Est. $516/mo*

27 days at this dealer

Solid BlackBlack

KIA of Riverdale

Riverdale, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,994

33,651 mi

Est. $526/mo*

27 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Prestige Toyota

Ramsey, NJ

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,294

33,138 mi

Est. $531/mo*

18 days at this dealer

Stealth GreyBlack

Automotive Avenues

Sewell, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,598

28,735 mi

Est. $535/mo*

20 days at this dealer

Lucas Chevrolet

Lumberton, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,650

25,317 mi

Est. $536/mo*

3 days at this dealer

White

Route 1 Hyundai

Monmouth Junction, NJ

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,799

17,990 mi

Est. $538/mo*

98 days at this dealer

BlueBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$36,898

39,899 mi

Est. $539/mo*

18 days at this dealer

Level Up

Newark, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$37,292

21,283 mi

Est. $545/mo*

39 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Carz4us of Pine Brook

Pine Brook, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$37,399

30,396 mi

Est. $546/mo*

18 days at this dealer

Space Auto Group

East Brunswick, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$37,866

29,088 mi

Est. $553/mo*

8 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Euro Lux Auto

Hillside, NJ

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$39,799

32,485 mi

Est. $580/mo*

3 days at this dealer

Space Auto Group

East Brunswick, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$40,584

35,250 mi

Est. $592/mo*

73 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

NJ Auto Haus

Elizabeth, NJ

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$40,586

19,258 mi

Est. $592/mo*

18 days at this dealer

QuicksilverBlack

Lester Glenn Subaru

Toms River, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$41,799

14,621 mi

Est. $609/mo*

47 days at this dealer

GrayBlack

CarVision of Maple Shade

Maple Shade, NJ

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$42,763

66,223 mi

Est. $623/mo*

34 days at this dealer

Black

Maserati of Bergen County

Upper Saddle River, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$43,495

54,200 mi

Est. $633/mo*

10 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Convey Motors

Hillside, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$45,789

23,601 mi

Est. $666/mo*

39 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

DCH Brunswick Toyota

North Brunswick, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$46,997

17,082 mi

Est. $683/mo*

12 days at this dealer

GrayBlack

Bell Audi

Edison, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$50,999

12,818 mi

Est. $740/mo*

10 days at this dealer

GrayBlack

Space Auto Group

East Brunswick, NJ

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$51,999

16,427 mi

Est. $754/mo*

10 days at this dealer

QuicksilverWhite/Black

Space Auto Group

East Brunswick, NJ