Tesla Model Y for Sale in Indiana

Live Tesla Model Y inventory in Indiana, priced low to high.

11 listings · $24,299 – $49,250

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$24,299

91,468 mi

Est. $360/mo*

18 days at this dealer

SilverBlack

Bob Thomas Ford Lincoln North

Fort Wayne, IN

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,091

75,592 mi

Est. $399/mo*

18 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Indy Auto Man - Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,502

58,606 mi

Est. $448/mo*

20 days at this dealer

Gray

Andy Mohr KIA

Avon, IN

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,995

56,576 mi

Est. $455/mo*

4 days at this dealer

GrayBlack

Andy Mohr Ford

Plainfield, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,145

30,215 mi

Est. $486/mo*

12 days at this dealer

BlueBlack

Kennedy Auto Finance

Hammond, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$34,050

37,470 mi

Est. $499/mo*

27 days at this dealer

WhiteBlack

Audi Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$34,400

26,181 mi

Est. $504/mo*

20 days at this dealer

Red Multi-CoatBlack

Auto Giant USA - Fishers

Fishers, IN

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$44,620

18,144 mi

Est. $649/mo*

10 days at this dealer

SilverWhite

Tom Kelley Cadillac

Fort Wayne, IN

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$46,194

15,378 mi

Est. $672/mo*

3 days at this dealer

BlackBlack

Legit Motors

Elkhart, IN

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Premium

$48,435

2,414 mi

Est. $704/mo*

3 days at this dealer

Stealth GrayBlack

Andy Mohr Toyota

Avon, IN

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$49,250

3,166 mi

Est. $715/mo*

Stealth GreyBlack

Unlimited Motors

Lafayette, IN