Tesla Model Y for Sale in Indiana

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,141

75,592 mi

Est. $400/mo*

78 days on market

WhiteBlack

Indy Auto Man - Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$27,212

118,582 mi

Est. $401/mo*

17 days on market

Penske Honda

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$27,261

76,527 mi

Est. $402/mo*

4 days on market

WhiteBlack

Indy Auto Man - Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$28,451

42,170 mi

Est. $419/mo*

106 days on market

SilverBlack

Tom Roush Mazda

Westfield, IN

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$28,548

76,329 mi

Est. $420/mo*

1 day on market

Red MultiBlack

Ray Skillman KIA West

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,188

61,375 mi

Est. $429/mo*

18 days on market

BlackBlack

Genesis of Merrillville

Merrillville, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$29,231

87,701 mi

Est. $430/mo*

62 days on market

WhiteBlack

Indy Auto Man - Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2020 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$30,280

50,176 mi

Est. $445/mo*

64 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

The Collection: Coast To Coast Imports

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2021 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$30,988

53,814 mi

Est. $455/mo*

1 day on market

BlueBlack

Fort Wayne Toyota

Fort Wayne, IN

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$32,716

93,608 mi

Est. $480/mo*

66 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Northside Auto

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$33,398

51,390 mi

Est. $489/mo*

3 days on market

BlackBlack

Hubler Chevrolet

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2022 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,681

29,169 mi

Est. $493/mo*

85 days on market

Red Multi-CoatWhite/Black

Northside Auto

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$33,851

35,362 mi

Est. $496/mo*

77 days on market

WhiteBlack

Auto Giant USA - Fishers

Fishers, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$34,210

52,845 mi

Est. $501/mo*

132 days on market

WhiteBlack

Northside Auto

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$34,511

31,026 mi

Est. $505/mo*

19 days on market

RedBlack

Shepherd's Chevrolet GMC of Wabash Inc.

Wabash, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$34,999

38,134 mi

Est. $512/mo*

63 days on market

Alderman Automotive

Fishers, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$35,169

15,083 mi

Est. $515/mo*

42 days on market

WhiteBlack

Ed Martin Acura

Indianapolis, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,199

31,490 mi

Est. $515/mo*

63 days on market

GrayBlack

Auto Import Specialist

South Bend, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$35,278

46,437 mi

Est. $516/mo*

9 days on market

RedWhite

Warsaw Buick GMC Chrysler Dodge Jeep RAM

Warsaw, IN

Used 2023 Tesla Model Y

Performance

$35,534

32,928 mi

Est. $520/mo*

15 days on market

SilverBlack

Lockhart Cadillac Greenwood

Greenwood, IN

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,500

33,100 mi

Est. $533/mo*

90 days on market

Solid BlackBlack

Unlimited Motors in Noblesville

Noblesville, IN

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$36,761

27,340 mi

Est. $537/mo*

54 days on market

Gray

Dreyer & Reinbold BMW INFINITI Subaru Volkswagen of Greenwood

Greenwood, IN

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$37,743

40,496 mi

Est. $551/mo*

9 days on market

GrayBlack

S&H Auto Group - Osceola

Osceola, IN

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$38,326

26,018 mi

Est. $560/mo*

74 days on market

BlueBlack

Preferred Auto Illinois Road

Fort Wayne, IN

Used 2024 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$40,151

9,051 mi

Est. $586/mo*

63 days on market

BlueBlack

Auto Giant USA - Fishers

Fishers, IN

Used 2025 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$40,500

12,550 mi

Est. $590/mo*

46 days on market

BlueSynthetic Seats

Unlimited motors

Westfield, IN

Used 2026 Tesla Model Y

Long Range

$46,768

18,895 mi

Est. $680/mo*

1 day on market

White

Penske Honda

Indianapolis, IN