BMW M5 for Sale in New York

Used 2008 BMW M5

Base

$14,999

138,616 mi

Est. $227/mo*

28 days on market

Sayarat Motors

Mahopac, NY

Used 2019 BMW M5

Competition

$42,854

91,881 mi

Est. $624/mo*

10 days on market

BlackSilverstone

McGovern Volvo Cars of Albany

Colonie, NY

Used 2019 BMW M5

Competition

$45,888

90,410 mi

Est. $667/mo*

55 days on market

Alpine WhiteBlack

Lemans Cars

Commack, NY

Used 2020 BMW M5

Competition

$53,170

72,000 mi

Est. $771/mo*

134 days on market

GrayBlack

Elite Auto World

East Meadow, NY

Used 2020 BMW M5

Competition

$56,795

70,396 mi

Est. $823/mo*

105 days on market

Alpine WhiteAragon Brown

Best Auto Outlet Inc.

Floral Park, NY

Used 2020 BMW M5

Competition

$57,170

74,259 mi

Est. $828/mo*

95 days on market

WhiteBlack

BQ AUTO GROUP Inc.

Ridgewood, NY

Used 2019 BMW M5

Competition

$59,675

43,333 mi

Est. $864/mo*

5 days on market

Alpine WhiteAragon Brown

Central Ave Nissan

Yonkers, NY

Used 2019 BMW M5

Competition

$67,995

43,707 mi

Est. $982/mo*

151 days on market

BlackBlack

Citywide Automotive North LLC

Amenia, NY

Used 2021 BMW M5

Competition

$69,500

45,782 mi

Est. $1,004/mo*

69 days on market

GrayBlack

Power Motors East

Massapequa Park, NY

Used 2021 BMW M5

Competition

$69,625

35,096 mi

Est. $1,006/mo*

9 days on market

Black

City Auto World

New York, NY

Used 2021 BMW M5

Competition

$70,894

50,100 mi

Est. $1,024/mo*

21 days on market

BlueAragon Brown

Freedom Chevrolet

Fort Montgomery, NY

Used 2023 BMW M5

Competition

$86,170

20,478 mi

Est. $1,241/mo*

114 days on market

Bay BlueBlack

South Shore Nissan

Amityville, NY

Used 2023 BMW M5

Competition

$98,174

15,804 mi

Est. $1,412/mo*

79 days on market

WhiteBlack

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY

Used 2021 BMW M5

Competition

$100,075

11,836 mi

Est. $1,440/mo*

221 days on market

ChalkBlack

Motorcar Classics

Farmingdale, NY

Used 2023 BMW M5

Competition

$100,170

6,572 mi

Est. $1,441/mo*

126 days on market

BlackSilverstone

South Shore Nissan

Amityville, NY

Used 2025 BMW M5

Base

$109,170

3,768 mi

Est. $1,569/mo*

81 days on market

Bay BlueBlack

South Shore Nissan

Amityville, NY

Used 2023 BMW M5

Competition

$110,174

17,831 mi

Est. $1,584/mo*

125 days on market

RedWhite

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY

Used 2025 BMW M5

Base

$113,165

17,500 mi

Est. $1,626/mo*

16 days on market

Green MetallicBlack

Starks Ford of Queens

Woodside, NY

Used 2025 BMW M5

Touring

$115,175

7,747 mi

Est. $1,655/mo*

133 days on market

BlackBlack

Habberstad KIA

Huntington, NY

Used 2025 BMW M5

Touring

$115,970

5,976 mi

Est. $1,666/mo*

157 days on market

BlackSilver / Black

Manhattan Motorcars

New York, NY

Used 2026 BMW M5

Base

$120,174

3,447 mi

Est. $1,726/mo*

20 days on market

GrayBlack

Wide World BMW

Spring Valley, NY

Used 2022 BMW M5

Competition

$125,174

11,696 mi

Est. $1,797/mo*

27 days on market

BlueBrown

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY

Used 2026 BMW M5

Touring

$127,350

5,062 mi

Est. $1,828/mo*

158 days on market

BlueBlack

Honda of the Bronx

Bronx, NY

New 2026 BMW M5

Base

$130,990

9 mi

Est. $1,880/mo*

133 days on market

GrayBlack

Habberstad BMW

Huntington Station, NY

New 2026 BMW M5

Base

$131,115

102 mi

Est. $1,882/mo*

55 days on market

BlackBlack

Competition BMW of Smithtown

Saint James, NY

New 2027 BMW M5

Base

$132,042

5 mi

Est. $1,895/mo*

7 days on market

BlackBlack

Orange County BMW

Harriman, NY

New 2026 BMW M5

Touring

$133,530

19 mi

Est. $1,916/mo*

141 days on market

BlackBlack

Rallye BMW

Westbury, NY

New 2027 BMW M5

Touring

$135,105

9 mi

Est. $1,939/mo*

26 days on market

GreenBlack

BMW of Bay Shore

Bay Shore, NY

Used 2022 BMW M5

Competition

$135,174

5,550 mi

Est. $1,940/mo*

16 days on market

GrayBrown

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY

New 2027 BMW M5

Base

$137,110

10 mi

Est. $1,967/mo*

46 days on market

Special Order ColorBlack

BMW Mt. Kisco

Mount Kisco, NY

New 2027 BMW M5

Base

$139,215

6 mi

Est. $1,997/mo*

7 days on market

Special Order ColorBlack

Rallye BMW

Westbury, NY

New 2026 BMW M5

Base

$146,952

3,623 mi

Est. $2,108/mo*

137 days on market

Frozen Deep GreRed/Black Exten

BMW of Manhattan

New York, NY

New 2027 BMW M5

Base

$151,397

5 mi

Est. $2,171/mo*

73 days on market

Rosso CorsaBlack Extended

BMW of Manhattan

New York, NY

Used 2022 BMW M5

CS

$160,174

23,831 mi

Est. $2,296/mo*

71 days on market

GrayBlack

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY

Used 2022 BMW M5

CS

$170,174

14,880 mi

Est. $2,439/mo*

48 days on market

GreenBlack

Brooklyn Auto Sales

Staten Island, NY