2009 Volkswagen Tiguan

The Tiguan is Volkswagen's compact SUV, a smaller and more car-like alternative to the Touareg, aimed at drivers who want SUV practicality without the bulk. The ride is on the soft side, soaking up bumps well, though the firm suspension can feel a bit busy over rough pavement. Inside, the cabin is logically laid out with simple controls, and the rear seats slide and fold to expand cargo space when you need it. Owners report good dependability overall, but a few have dealt with electrical gremlins and premature tire wear, so a warranty is worth having. If you want a compact SUV that drives more like a car than a truck, the Tiguan is it, and this SEL trim adds leather and a sunroof over the base S. The 2.0L I4 makes 200 horsepower and pairs with a six-speed automatic that snaps off quick shifts, and the all-wheel drive gives you all-weather grip without a heavy feel. The SEL's standard panoramic sunroof floods the cabin with light, but the firm suspension means you'll feel expansion joints more than in a RAV4.