2012 BMW X5 xDrive35d

The 2012 X5 is BMW's mid-size luxury SUV, the one people cross-shop against the Mercedes-Benz ML and Audi Q7. It drives with a planted, heavy feel that makes you trust it in corners and on the highway, though the ride is on the firm side. The cabin is roomy for four adults, and the split tailgate is a handy touch for loading gear or tailgating. Owners mention occasional electrical gremlins and pricey maintenance, so a thorough service history matters here. Diesel torque and better fuel economy set the xDrive35d apart from the gasoline xDrive35i, though it costs more upfront. Its 3.0L I6 makes 265 horsepower and a hefty 425 lb-ft of torque, paired with a six-speed automatic and all-wheel drive, so it pulls hard from low revs without drama.