2010 Toyota Tacoma

The Tacoma is Toyota's mid-size pickup, a body-on-frame truck that's been a steady seller for years. It drives like a proper truck, with a sturdy feel and a ride that's a bit bouncy when empty, but it handles rough roads with confidence. The cabin is simple and functional, with durable materials and plenty of room up front, though rear legroom is tight in the Access Cab. Owners report that these trucks are extremely reliable, with many going well past 200,000 miles, though some mention a driveline vibration at highway speeds. The PreRunner gives you the lifted stance and off-road suspension of the four-wheel-drive model but with rear-wheel drive to save weight and cost. Its 4.0L V6 makes 236 horsepower and pairs with a five-speed automatic, which is plenty for daily driving but returns 18 mpg combined.